Moving to Worthington Ohio — historic New England cupola architecture and walkable storefronts along High Street in Old Worthington

Worthington

Neighborhood Guide

Most Columbus suburbs started as a developer's plat. Worthington started as a promise.

Last reviewed: November 2026

TYPICAL HOME PRICES

$525K single-family · $258K condo

Closed MLS sales Nov. 2025 – Nov. 2026

SCHOOLS

Worthington City Schools · Thomas Worthington & Kilbourne

Verify every 43085 parcel

LOCATION + ACCESS

12 o'clock on I-270 (US-23 & SR-161)

~15 min to Downtown, OSU & CMH

PROPERTY TAXES

Among Franklin County's heavier school millages

City of Worthington vs. Columbus 43085 matters

What It’s Like to Live Here

Most Columbus suburbs started as a developer's plat. Worthington started as a promise: in 1803, settlers from New England laid out a village green where High Street now meets SR-161, and the town has been growing outward from that square ever since. That's why it feels rooted rather than planned, more Connecticut than master-planned community.

From May through October, Saturday mornings belong to the outdoor Worthington Farmers Market on High Street and the Village Green, followed by a slow browse through the independent shops along High Street. Summer evenings end with families and kids perched on the benches and low walls outside Graeter's Ice Cream. Come December, the holiday lights across Old Worthington and the Village Green give the whole town an unmistakable Hallmark-movie Christmas feel.

Buyers who want mature trees, classic community traditions and top-rated schools without the flashier new-money feel of some outer suburbs.

Getting Around

Worthington sits at 12 o'clock on I-270, so most of Central Ohio is a short drive away. High Street (US-23) and SR-161 cross at the Village Green, SR-315 runs just west and I-71 is minutes east, putting Downtown, OSU and CMH Airport about 15 minutes away off-peak. The catch is 5 p.m., when High Street, 161, 270 and 315 all funnel together and Old Worthington backs up fast. We plan around it by leaving before 4:30 or after 6.

Schools + Boundaries

Worthington City Schools is the draw, but a 43085 mailing address doesn't guarantee it. Old Worthington feels compact, but the district reaches north toward the Powell area today, and Thomas Worthington, the original of its two high schools alongside Worthington Kilbourne, just wrapped a complete campus makeover. Because 43085 spans parts of the Worthington, Columbus and Westerville districts, we check every parcel's exact school and tax district on the Franklin County Auditor's site before you settle on a home.

Property Taxes

Worthington's school levies are among the heaviest in Franklin County, and the bills show it. The Worthington City School District's effective residential rate (49.75 mills for tax year 2024) runs well above neighbors like Westerville and Bexley, and Census figures put the median city bill around $7,500. True City of Worthington parcels get perks like leaf collection and Community Center resident rates; Columbus-side 43085 parcels are taxed and served by Columbus instead. Two similar houses a few blocks apart can carry noticeably different bills.

Homes + Market

Worthington's housing is largely built out, so you're choosing between a piece of history and a solid mid-century home you'll likely want to update. Near Old Worthington, you'll find early-1800s originals and 1920s homes on intimate lots, where the Architectural Review Board signs off on exterior changes before work begins.

Fan out from the center and the streets fill with 1950s–60s ranches, Cape Cods and split-levels under big canopy trees. With almost no open land left, "new construction" usually means a rare $1M+ infill tear-down, and inventory stays tight: the city's MLS supply sat under one month this spring.

What’s Changing

Former United Methodist Children's Home site (1033 High St.): In January 2026, the Sixth Circuit sided with the city over Lifestyle Communities' rejected rezoning. What happens next on these 37 acres across from the Municipal Building is the question every local is asking.

Northeast Area Plan: Adopted in July 2024, it aims to turn the Huntley Road and Proprietors Road industrial corridor into an "Eco Innovation District."

High Street and SR-161 corridor work: City capital plans include High Street curb, sidewalk and repaving work from the south city line to South Street, plus SR-161/Linworth Road intersection improvements.

Local’s List

Eat & Drink

The Whitney House

Elevated comfort food and a High Street patio. It's our go-to for "nice, not fussy."

Joya's

Top Chef alum Avishar Barua's Bengali-inspired café, named for his mom. Go early on weekends.

La Chatelaine

Classic French bakery and bistro for croissants, quiche and an unhurried weekday lunch.

Greenspaces

The Village Green

The heart of town, where the market, summer concerts and Market Day all happen.

Olentangy Trail & Antrim Park

Paved trail miles plus a lake loop, just a quick hop down 315.

Highbanks Metro Park

Wooded bluffs and ravine trails a few minutes north up Route 23.

Only in Worthington

Worthington Farmers Market

Our summer Saturday ritual, May through October, filling High Street and the Village Green with Central Ohio's largest market.

Old Worthington Market Day

The town's biggest one-day festival each fall, with 160+ artisan booths along High Street.

Concerts on the Green

Lawn chairs, live music and the whole neighborhood out on summer evenings.

A Pocket to Know

Old Worthington

  • The Vibe: The original 1803 town plan, built around the Village Green where High Street meets SR-161. Brick sidewalks, church steeples and deep front porches make it feel more New England village than Columbus suburb.
  • On-Site Perks: The summer Saturday farmers market, independent shops along High Street, and Joya's, The Whitney House, La Chatelaine and Graeter's all a short stroll away. In December, the holiday lights turn it into a Hallmark-movie Christmas town.
  • The Homes: Early-1800s originals and 1920s classics, plus a handful of carefully fitted newer builds. Listings are rare, so we watch this pocket closely.
  • The Catch: The historic core sits inside the city's Architectural Review District, so exterior changes like windows, additions and even some fences need Architectural Review Board approval. Lots are tight, garages tend to be small or detached, and Market Day means road closures at your doorstep.

— See it in person

See Worthington With Us

Listings only get you so far. Come see which streets fit your life, and which tradeoffs you can actually live with.

Prefer to talk first? or

We’ll only use your details to respond to your message.

See our Website Privacy Policy for how we handle what you send.

If You Like Worthington, Also Look At...

Explore all neighborhood guides

Sources: City of Worthington · Worthington City Schools · Franklin County Auditor · Haven MLS data · U.S. Census Bureau · Columbus & Franklin County Metro Parks · individual organizations and businesses where noted