Moving to Delaware Ohio — historic three-story brick architecture and Bun's Restaurant sign along Sandusky Street in Downtown Delaware

Delaware

Neighborhood Guide

Delaware County has grown fast, yet the historic heart around Sandusky Street has kept its genuine small-town feel.

Last reviewed: November 2026

TYPICAL HOME PRICES

$380K single-family · $275K condo

Closed Matrix MLS sales, Delaware CSD, Nov. 2025 – Nov. 2026

SCHOOLS

Delaware City Schools

Some 43015 edges feed Olentangy Local

LOCATION + ACCESS

12 o'clock, ~10 miles north of I-270

Downtown 30–35 min · CMH 35–40 min

PROPERTY TAXES

Delaware County · 1.85% city income tax

Olentangy parcels run higher

What It’s Like to Live Here

For decades, Delaware was the sleepy college town wrapped around Ohio Wesleyan University. If you grew up in Columbus, you probably knew it best as the last McDonald's and gas stop on US-23 before Bucyrus, with the whole car counting down the miles to Cedar Point.

That picture has changed fast. Delaware County has grown into one of the fastest-growing counties in Ohio, and new subdivisions now stretch far across the county. Yet the historic heart around Sandusky Street has kept its genuine small-town feel, with brick storefronts, the courthouse, and OWU students crossing downtown on foot.

On a normal Tuesday, it's coffee on Sandusky Street, school pickup, and a quick grocery run before the US-23 commute home. Saturdays slow down: a big breakfast at the Hamburger Inn, a lap through downtown, and an afternoon on the water at Alum Creek.

Buyers who want a real downtown and old-house character, and who don't mind trading a few commute minutes for it.

Getting Around

Delaware sits due north on US-23: close enough to Polaris for errands, but a real drive to Downtown and the airport. Off-peak, Polaris is about 15 minutes straight south and Downtown Columbus is 30–35 minutes. Rush hour is the catch: US-23 crawls between town and Polaris, and on the east side traffic still bunches at The Point (US-36/SR-37 under the railroad bridge) and along the SR-37/US-42 corridor. Freight trains blocking east-west crossings are part of daily life here, and CMH runs about 35–40 minutes.

Schools + Boundaries

A 43015 Delaware mailing address covers a massive area, and it can put you in either of two very different school districts. Most of the city and the historic core attend Delaware City Schools, feeding Rutherford B. Hayes High School. Newer subdivisions on the southern and eastern edges of 43015, toward Lewis Center and Cheshire, often feed Olentangy Local Schools (usually Olentangy Berlin or Olentangy High School), with significantly higher home prices and school tax rates to match. We verify every parcel's exact school and tax boundary before you settle on a home.

Property Taxes

Two similar-priced homes with the same 43015 address can carry noticeably different tax bills. Everything here sits in Delaware County, but the school district on the parcel drives much of the property tax rate, and Olentangy parcels typically run higher than Delaware City Schools parcels. Inside city limits you'll also pay Delaware's 1.85% income tax; homes out in the surrounding townships don't. Voters turned down a city income tax increase in 2024, and the credit for tax paid where you work has been part of the budget debate since, so check the current credit.

Homes + Market

Delaware gives you three distinct housing eras within a few miles: Victorian-era homes downtown, mid-century streets around them, and newer subdivisions on the edges. The tree-lined streets near downtown and OWU are lined with big, classic Victorian and Queen Anne homes that give off a true Victorian Village vibe at a fraction of Short North and Victorian Village prices. Plenty have been beautifully updated; others still need wiring, plumbing, or windows brought into this century, so plan on an inspection that looks closely.

Around that core, 1950s–70s neighborhoods of ranches, split-levels, and two-stories make some of the best first-home buys in town. Farther out, sprawling newer subdivisions on the south and east sides bring open floor plans and bigger garages, and that's also where you're most likely to cross into Olentangy schools and higher prices.

What’s Changing

The Point wraps up: The multi-year widening of US-36/SR-37 under the Norfolk Southern bridge on the east side is in its final stretch, easing one of the city's worst bottlenecks.

SR-37 and US-42 corridor: The city is lining up a phased project on SR-37 between US-23 and US-36, including the Lake Street (US-42) intersection.

Downtown hotel and east-side growth: The city is seeking a developer for a downtown hotel, while a new Kroger Marketplace on Sunbury Road and large new subdivisions keep pushing growth outward.

Local’s List

Eat & Drink

Hamburger Inn Diner

Grab a counter seat for a big breakfast and one of those giant cinnamon rolls.

Bun's Restaurant

A Sandusky Street institution that's been feeding Delaware since 1864.

Opa Grill & Tavern

Mediterranean plates plus one of Central Ohio's deepest, most impressive bourbon selections.

Amato's Woodfired Pizza

Our go-to downtown whenever we want a wood-fired pie.

Coffeeology & Old Dog Alehouse

Morning coffee and evening craft beer, both right on Sandusky Street.

Greenspaces

Alum Creek State Park

Boating, a beach, and mountain-bike and hiking trails just minutes southeast of town.

Delaware State Park

A second state park close to town for lake days, camping, and quiet walks.

Mingo Park / Olentangy River

Close-in green space and river views for an easy after-dinner outing.

Only in Delaware

Downtown Delaware First Fridays

Streets close, music starts, and it feels like the whole town came downtown at once.

The Little Brown Jug

Every September at the Delaware County Fair, one of harness racing's most famous races fills the grandstands.

A Pocket to Know

Historic Downtown Delaware

  • The Vibe: Sandusky and Winter Streets are the reason a lot of people choose Delaware over a newer suburb—historic brick storefronts, the county courthouse, and a true small-town main street.
  • On-Site Perks: The independent food and drink scene—from Hamburger Inn and Bun's Restaurant to Opa Grill & Tavern, Amato's Woodfired Pizza, Coffeeology, and Old Dog Alehouse—punches way above its weight, and First Fridays fill the streets with neighbors.
  • The Homes: Classic Victorian and Queen Anne homes on tree-lined blocks just steps from downtown and Ohio Wesleyan University.
  • The Catch: Older Victorians require careful inspection for wiring, plumbing, and windows, and freight trains along the east-side tracks occasionally slow cross-town traffic.

— See it in person

See Delaware With Us

Listings only get you so far. Come see which streets fit your life, and which tradeoffs you can actually live with.

Prefer to talk first? or

We’ll only use your details to respond to your message.

See our Website Privacy Policy for how we handle what you send.

If You Like Delaware, Also Look At...

Explore all neighborhood guides

Sources: City of Delaware · Delaware City Schools · Olentangy Local Schools · Delaware County Auditor · Haven MLS data · Ohio Department of Natural Resources · individual organizations and businesses where noted